Only if you like monkeying with that hard top all the way until the weather clears. I had Oldyj's old hard top for a single season, and liked it until the weather was nice in dec., jan, feb, etc. and I saw all the other Heepers running around with their tops dropped & doors off. Sold it right after that. Unless you drive a ton of miles to work on the highway, most likely you'll hate the hard top in a season or 2. Hold on to the soft top as a back up plan, unless you need cash for other upgrades.....or rent.....or groceries....I'm sure you get the picture.